The Common Application
By Benjamin Lo, Dartmouth College ‘09
Congratulations! You’ve now decided to embark on the grand journey of applying for an American university. The glamour, the excitement, having more seasons than wet season and wetter season; all these and more await you!
But first, there’s a significant downside – You have to apply.
Let’s start with a few clarifications about the application process.
-
American applications are uncommonly long and complicated.
-
They are also almost exclusively tailored for those who have had American-style educations.
-
Much of this tedium is removed by the Common Application, which sends the same application to all the colleges you want to go to.
-
However, not all colleges use the Common App, and even then, colleges included in the Common App always require additional, supplementary forms to be submitted.
The Common App (www.commonapp.org) consists of several forms, namely the main Common Application, a Mid-year Report, a School Report, 2 Teacher Evaluations and various supplementary forms. In this article, what I hope to do is explain how to fill out everything in the main Common Application (except for the essays, unfortunately those can’t be filled out quite so easily), the Mid-year Report and the School Report. This information is based on the print version of the Common App; the online version will be up and available sometime later this year.
Common Application Form:
The first thing that you need to fill out when completing the Common Application is the ED/EA/REA section. Remember, you need to make multiple copies of your paper application (non-applicable if you are using the online forms) and send one copy to each college. If you decide to apply ED, EA or REA to College X, indicate so on the top of one form and send them only that form.
Personal Data:
Most of this stuff is self-explanatory. The main problem might arise in how you choose to have your name represented. If you have a Chinese name like Ng Eng Han, place the surname “Ng” as the last name, and Eng Han as the first. Your final college name will then be Eng Han Ng. However, if you have a trickier name like Benjamin Lo Hien Pin, then generally what works is having “Lo” as your last name, “Benjamin” as your first, and put down “Hien Pin” or “Hien-Pin” as your middle name. Now you can be Benjamin H. Lo.
Also in this section: It is not necessary to select possible areas of academic concentration. Some confusion may occasionally arise regarding the American college system. Unlike the UK, you do not need to pre-select courses before you go in, and the success of your application is certainly not determined by what course you pick, since there are no fixed spaces for whichever major you decide to do in the future. Likewise for “Possible career or professional plans.” So go ahead – pick undecided if that’s what you are. That being said, selecting an interesting academic concentration or possible career may play well into your essays when you write about your interests and passions.
There is a loaded question close to the end of this section: Will you be a candidate for financial aid? Remember, while most colleges in the US are need-blind, very few are actually need-blind for international students. Should you apply for financial aid at a need-aware college, your admission will depend partly on whether they can afford to give you financial aid.
Educational Data:
When filling out the “secondary school” section, I was usually torn between putting down secondary school information and pre-university information. This situation rarely arises for students studying in American systems, since most of them apply directly after our equivalent of Form 5. However, for those of us who did various pre-university programs such as A-Levels, STPM or IB, it becomes a bit more complicated. If you are enrolled or were previously enrolled in a Pre-U program, fill that out as your secondary school. Your “original” secondary school will later be filled out in the School Report, while your Pre-U program can be represented in the Mid-Year report.
Most schools in Malaysia should not have a CEEB/ACT code, though interestingly enough, some Singaporean junior colleges do. Leave this blank if you don’t know what it is.
As for your school counselor, we have to face the fact that school counselors in Malaysia are generally less involved than the ones in America. I would suggest that if you’ve never seen your school counselor in your life and you aren’t confident about his/her ability to fully represent you as a student, then consider approaching a favorite teacher and asking them to act as a counselor on your behalf. Again, make a note to explain why this replacement is necessary: there’s no reason to be ashamed of our terrible education system.
Finally, if you attended a peculiar program like the Singapore A-Levels, which puts you in the relaxing position of graduating in November and hence having nothing to do when applying, check “Not currently attending school” and remember to make a note of it in additional information.
Test Information:
You should have this all covered. However, if you have more than 2 SAT II subjects, pick the highest ones and find some way to mention the rest later on.
Family:
Again, pretty much self-explanatory. Use the same naming system as before.
Extracurricular, Personal and Volunteer Activities:
This is the big one. When looking at either the online or print form, one gets a sinking sense of despair with the miniscule amount of space allotted for this section. To rectify this horrifying shortage of space, first select your top 5 activities in both pre-university and secondary school. What criteria should you use to select activities? Generally, choose more recent ones. So it may be advisable to pick Public Speaking in Form 4 and 5, rather than Story-Telling in Form 1. Pick activities that you have participated in for extended periods of time, such as Red Crescent from Form 1 to Form 5. Naturally, pick activities that have “oomph” (you define oomph yourself) and prioritize activities where you have held clear leadership roles and can talk about significant contributions. Fill out all the necessary boxes and columns on the forms.
Next, prepare a table that you will attach as a supplementary document. This table should contain all the columns that the Activity section of the Common App has, but with one crucial addition: A “Description” column. If you want, you could add a few more activities on this sheet, if there are some that you couldn’t bear to leave out entirely. Keep the list of activities short and limit your descriptions to 2 or 3 sentences; admissions officials are pressed for time. The descriptions of your activities will go a long way towards imprinting your achievements on readers as well as improving their understanding of how you spent your years.
Academic Honors:
Briefly fill out this section with a list of the Academic Honors you may have received, for example book prizes in school, New South Wales International Competitions, Kuiz Sains Nasional and so on. Indicate that you have a separate sheet attached, and again prepare a table with the relevant columns, not forgetting the descriptions. Remember, American admissions officials will most likely have no experience with local competitions and may thus need some guidance in recognizing the true value of what you’ve achieved.
Personal Essay:
This, unfortunately, will take significantly more time and resources than any other part of the Common App. For advice on this section, wait for the next issue of this newsletter!
The School Report
This will be the form you use to detail your secondary school life. Something to note, though: Given that school counselors vary in quality and involvement, if you have another school official that knows you better, have him/her fill out this form instead. The moral of this story is: It might be a good idea to be nice to the Pengetua or Penolong Kanan.
Current Year Courses:
Fill out all the subjects you took in SPM or its equivalent and include the grade received next to it. Again, make a note to yourself to explain (in a supplementary letter) these subjects and grades. Don’t forget to add a certified photocopy of your results!
Waiver:
You should waive your right to see this report: Generally, its seen as the more responsible thing to do.
Counselor Section:
If your selected “counselor” has had little or no experience with the American system, fear not. Before he/she fills out this section, make sure you do all the groundwork. Arrange meetings between your counselor and subject teachers so that he/she can listen to them vouch enthusiastically for your shining brilliance and remarkable genius. Consult your principal regarding class ranks on how it should be filled out, if your school does not release official ranks. GPA is also rarely used in secondary schools, and as such you may elect to leave it blank, or fill out letter grades instead.
Malaysian public schools usually do not take classes on a block schedule, and don’t offer AP classes. However, in filling out his/her evaluation of your course selection, a good criterion to use may be the number of SPM subjects taken, as well as the subjects themselves. Much as I hate to endorse the grade-chasing nature of SPM, this might still be the simplest quantitative calculation of course difficulty.
Ultimately, this entire section has to be discussed with your counselor, various school teachers and school officials. Unless your counselor has had plenty of experience filling out such forms and knows exactly what to do, make sure that you explain how each section should be filled out and what should be taken into consideration. Finally, ensure that all these changes are noted down and explained in a supplementary letter, so that admissions readers understand why you could not follow the template exactly, as well as what criteria were used in determining these statistics. In fact, it would be even better if your school could produce and sign that explanatory letter themselves.
Ratings:
Again, self-explanatory. The key thing to note here is the discrepancy between international ratings and American-system ratings. Typical Asian reticence tends to raise the bar for “outstanding” and “one of the top few” as compared to Western teachers (though I may be generalizing). In theory, admissions readers are supposed to account for this bias towards understatement, but in practice this may not always be the case.
Evaluation:
Read the articles on Teacher Evaluations for a handle on what a good evaluation should cover.
Mid Year Report
The Mid-Year report has the exact same format as the School Report. However, for our purposes, we’re going to use it to detail Pre-University education. Thus, you may need to contact a different set of teachers and school officials to fill out this form, as well as liaise and explain the various intricacies of the form like you did in the School Report. Remember to state in the explanatory letter what you picked for each report and why you had to separate your secondary and pre-university education into two different reports.
Additional Stuff?
By now, you’ve probably realized that every time any confusion arises, I’ve mentioned a supplementary/explanatory letter. Sadly, it’s true. The Common App forms are at best, a rough fit to the international student experience. While admissions readers are supposed to be well-versed in the various systems, it never hurts to explain (briefly though!) what’s different about your system and how you’ve attempted to characterize and account for these differences in your application. To summarize quickly, the key differences you might look out for are: Educational Data in the Common App form, Course Selection, SPM or equivalent grades (America does not have national tests aside from the SATs), Class Ranks and GPA. Fill these out with the closest approximation you can find, explain them clearly and all should be well.
Keep in mind that several US colleges have a unique application supplement for the international student. If they do, it should be displayed in the “International Student” portion of their website under “Applying to XYZ College”. This usually makes it much easier for you to report your grades and school system, because you won’t have to change your SPM A1 into a US grade.
The most important thing you should remember is, when in doubt, email an admissions officer. Most colleges will have admissions officer specially in charge of international students, and they will be most happy to help you with your logistical or technical difficulty. Do not think that by asking questions you will be messing up your chance of admission into the college. Much the contrary, sometimes simple technical mistakes will nullify your whole application. So, please, please do not hesitate to email the college in question if you have questions about something.
The common application is a necessary evil, but for international students it usually comes across as more evil than necessary. However, keep in mind that it is a doable process and that many seniors have gone through it and come out on the other side. I do hope that this article has made the common application easier for you to navigate.
Benjamin Lo completed his A-Levels in Singapore and is a rising sophomore in Dartmouth College. He plans to major in Government and Economics and retire as soon as possible.